Coming in strong at number four, the Strawberry Milkshake Pop-Tart is a fan-favorite, with shoppers reminiscing fondly about enjoying the flavor since childhood. "Strawberry Milkshake and Hot Fudge ...

The adults weren't as excited, however, which is one reason that this flavor ended up lower on our list. Pop-Tarts aren't known for being that close to nature, but the bright blue was a little off ...

Created as a quick breakfast option, Pop-Tarts quickly became a household name thanks to their perfect blend of portability and flavor. Over the years, the brand has expanded its range ...

“Cookies and cream pop tart ice cream,” posited another. While we'd love a hot fudge sundae flavor, we’ll totally settle for these for now. A win is a win, right?